Vanilla Cacao Nib Peanut Butter

This post may contain affiliate links for products that I endorse and use. If you buy from one of the links, I earn a commission at no cost to you.

Last week, my husband opened up the cabinet we use as a pantry, looking for something. Nuts, pasta, crackers. It’s impossible to know. Especially considering I have everything under the sun in that cabinet shoved however it will fit. I guess some people might say I’m a bit disorganized.
Vanilla Cacao Nib Peanut Butter
So out come several jars of nut butters. Different flavors and brands. Almond, peanut, coconut. Some are those natural kind that get kind of hard when you get to the bottom. But too many nut butters, that’s for sure. At least according to him.
Vanilla Cacao Nib Peanut Butter
Rather than buy some more, I thought I’d try my hand at making my own. How hard can it be? Turns out not very. Because I don’t want to eat plain peanut butter, I added a couple things to make it a bit better. Vanilla extract, for one. Cacao nibs for two, because these seem healthier than chocolate chips and add a nice crunch.
Vanilla Cacao Nib Peanut Butter
Roasted peanuts are best here, and you’ll probably need to add some oil to help the peanuts along, especially if you like your peanut butter creamy. I’ve done this in both my Vitamix and a food processor, and while it’s possible in both, the food processor is better.
Vanilla Cacao Nib Peanut Butter

Vanilla Cacao Nib Peanut Butter

Crunchy homemade peanut butter with fragrant vanilla and cacao nibs.
No ratings yet


  • 2 cups roasted salted peanuts
  • 1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract
  • 1/4 cup cacao nibs
  • Peanut oil


  • Put the peanuts and vanilla in a food processor or powerful blender. Process until ground, and keep blending until you have a paste. At this point, you’ll need to add some oil, maybe a teaspoon or so, to keep it moving. Add the nibs and keep blending until you have the texture you want, continuing to add oil a tiny bit at a time.
  • Store in a jar either in the fridge or at room temperature.
Nutrition information is only an estimate provided by an online nutrition calculator. View full nutrition disclousre.
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!


Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating